The Short Answer
Compare Vivian Health and Aya Healthcare for travel nurses. See which platform offers better pay, more jobs, and better user experience.
Read the full breakdown below for detailed analysis, examples, and actionable steps.
Vivian vs. Aya: Travel Nurse Job Platform Comparison
Vivian Health and Aya Healthcare represent two different approaches to travel nursing: a job marketplace platform vs. a traditional agency. Here’s how they compare.
Quick Comparison
| Factor | Vivian Health | Aya Healthcare |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Job Marketplace | Traditional Agency |
| Average Pay | $2,200-3,000/week | $2,200-3,000/week |
| Job Volume | Very High | Very High |
| Support | Self-Service | Full Recruiter Support |
| Benefits | Varies by Agency | Comprehensive |
Platform Model
Vivian Health: A job marketplace where multiple agencies post jobs. You apply directly to jobs from various agencies through one platform.
Aya Healthcare: A traditional agency with dedicated recruiters who help you find and secure contracts.
Pay Comparison
Both platforms offer competitive pay rates. Aya Healthcare may offer slightly higher pay for direct placements, while Vivian allows you to compare rates across multiple agencies.
Winner: Tie - Both offer competitive rates, but Aya may have slight edge for direct placements.
Job Availability
Vivian Health aggregates jobs from multiple agencies, giving you access to thousands of positions. Aya Healthcare has their own extensive network of facilities.
Winner: Vivian for volume, Aya for curated opportunities.
Support & Benefits
Aya Healthcare provides comprehensive recruiter support and benefits. Vivian’s support and benefits depend on which agency you work with through the platform.
Winner: Aya Healthcare for consistent support and benefits.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Vivian Health if:
- You want to compare jobs from multiple agencies
- You prefer self-service job searching
- You want maximum job visibility
Choose Aya Healthcare if:
- You want dedicated recruiter support
- You prefer comprehensive benefits
- You want a traditional agency experience
Bottom Line
Vivian Health offers more job options through a marketplace model, while Aya Healthcare provides better support and benefits through a traditional agency model. Use our travel nurse pay calculator to compare potential earnings.
Get Matched with Top-Paying Recruiters
Connect with agencies offering the best contracts in your specialty
Ready to calculate your exact take-home pay? Use our Travel Nurse Pay Calculator.
Calculate your exact take-home pay, compare contracts, and see how stipends affect your net income.
Go to Calculator